Skip to main content

A Little History #12: Leo Eloesser, Frida Kahlo, and Trotsky by Tom McDermott

 

In April 2021 I wrote a mini-series of four articles on UNICEF's early days in China. Rereading them recently, it seemed to me that I was missing a piece on Leo Eloesser who played such an important role in China but in UNICEF's thinking on community medicine and primary health care. He only worked with UNICEF for a very short time—5 years—but they were momentous years for UNICEF and for him. In this article I write only about his history before and after UNICEF. The story of his brief period with UNICEF will come in the next article, The Shijiazhuang Strategy.

One of the most interesting, colorful, and important characters in UNICEF's early history was Dr. Leo Eloesser. In what remains the best and most comprehensive book on UNICEF's history, The Children and the Nations, Maggie Black describes how the newly arrived first representative of UNICEF in China, Dr. Marcel Junod, recruited Eloesser from UNRRA to serve as his emissary to parts of China under Communist control. She also describes the critical role Eloesser played in standardizing the training of community health care workers and the development of a standard midwifery kit.

Outside UNICEF Eloesser is more widely remembered for his relationship with two of the best-known avant-garde artists of the time: Frida Kahlo and Diego Rivera. Yet aside from a few familiar with the art world of those days, few would recognize Leo Eloesser's name today.

So who was Leo Eloesser?

Music vs. Medicine

Leo Eloesser was born in San Francisco on July 29, 1881, to wealthy German immigrant parents who had built a successful business manufacturing sturdy workingmen's overalls—the "Can't Bust 'Em" brand. His early passion was music, not medicine. That dream never fully left him. Throughout his life, wherever he traveled—to war zones, remote villages, battlefields—his viola went with him.


A Fortune Built on Can't Bust-em Overalls


Leo's father pushed him toward medicine rather than music. The initial result was disastrous. At UC Berkeley, he failed most of his classes. As he would later recall, "Music filled my head; I wandered about alone, I lived in a world apart." His father intervened, and Leo became a more focused student, graduating with honors and a bachelor of science degree in 1900.

Learning surgery with Vincenz Czerny at Heidelberg

On the advice of a family friend, Leo then enrolled to study medicine at the University of Heidelberg in Germany, where he studied under the renowned surgeon Vincenz Czerny. He thrived in the German academic scene, which he found remarkably free and stimulating after the strict regimen at Berkeley. Under Czerny, he also adopted an approach to risky surgeries that few American surgeons would have attempted at the time. He was awarded his MD on February 5, 1907.

With his microscope

After postdoctoral work in Germany and a brief stint at a laboratory in London, Eloesser returned to San Francisco in 1910. He completed a clinical internship at San Francisco General Hospital and joined the faculty at Stanford Medical School in 1912, building a reputation as a brilliant thoracic surgeon. With financial support from his father, he also opened a private practice.

But Eloesser was never a conventional surgeon. Even in these early years, he refused to charge the high fees common among other surgeons. He treated impoverished and low-income patients, often charging nothing or a tiny fraction of his standard fees. His private practice struggled as a result.

The financial struggle never impeded his interest in San Francisco's vibrant art and music scene. It was there in 1926 that he came to know the Mexican muralist Diego Rivera, whose fame in the US and Europe was growing rapidly.

Los Tres Amigos: Rivera, Kahlo, and Eloesser

Diego and Frida

In 1929 Diego Rivera married a little-known artist, Frida Kahlo and brought her to San Francisco in 1930. Diego and Frida were an odd couple. Rivera was a large man, already famous, wealthy, and twenty years older than Frida. She was small, delicate, unknown as an artist, and suffering lifelong pain from an accident with a street trolley. Her parents called the marriage "the union of an elephant and a dove."

Frida and Diego lived in San Francisco from 1930 to 1931, and Diego asked Eloesser to treat Frida's chronic pain. Over several months Eloesser successfully treated her agonizing leg pain and chronic medical issues. Frida came to trust Eloesser completely.

A remarkable correspondence developed between them. Long after both had died, Frida's letters to Leo would be published as Las cartas de Frida Kahlo a Leo Eloesser—an intimate sharing of her feelings, traumas, marriage struggles, and inner anguish. Leo was now more than her physician; he was her confidant and confessor.


Frida's Self-portrait -"I painted my portrait in the year 1940 for Doctor Leo Eloesser, my doctor and my best friend."

Before leaving San Francisco in 1931, Frida painted the Portrait of Dr. Leo Eloesser. She included in the painting a model sailing ship in the background—representing the sail boat Eloesser owned and sailed in San Francisco Bay. Frida painted the ship and inscribed it with the name Los Tres Amigos—The Three Friends—marking the unbreakable bond she foresaw between Eloesser, Diego, and herself.

Portrait of Dr. Leo Eloesser by Frida Kahlo

When she and Diego moved on, she started a series of letters to Eloesser, referring to him as her doctorcito—her dear little doctor. When Frida and Diego returned to Mexico in 1931, her correspondence with him continued deepening into one of the most intimate documented relationships of that era.

Life would test that bond in ways none of them could have foreseen. Within a decade, Frida would return to Eloesser's care not as a patient seeking routine medical treatment, but as a desperately sick and traumatized woman who had experienced betrayal, divorce, the murder of her former lover, the terror of being accused of involvement in his murder, and a spiral into despair and alcohol.

We will return to that story later.

TB and the Flap

Readers will have noted that Marcel Junod, like Eloesser, was a thoracic surgeon who was also a war surgeon. So were many other surgeons of those years. The reason is simply that tuberculosis was the number one disease challenge of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. It was known as "the white death". War was an equally common killer in the early 20th Century.

After Robert Koch first isolated the TB bacterium in 1882, the central challenge for physicians became how to address the massive buildup of pus that accumulated in the area around the lungs. Lethal secondary infections frequently followed any attempt to drain the lungs, forcing surgeons to search for ways to protect the chest and prevent catastrophic collapse. Antibiotics were not yet available in these years.

Convalescence - long, expensive and often unsuccessful

Treatment was a long, painful, and expensive process in hospitals, making it largely unavailable to most who suffered from the disease. Prior to the widespread availability of antibiotics in the late 1940s, a diagnosis of active tuberculosis (TB) was effectively a death sentence for the vast majority of patients. Historically, about 60% to 80% of patients with untreated active TB would die from the disease, typically within five to ten years of diagnosis.

To the challenge of TB was added the horrific lung and chest wounds of modern warfare. In addition to shattered chests from conventional injuries, an estimated 90,000 to 100,000 people died directly from poison gas use in WWI, with hundreds of thousands more suffering severe, chronic respiratory trauma and secondary lung infections. Added to these figures were thousands more when chemical weapons were deployed in subsequent conflicts in Ethiopia and Morocco. Chest and lung care in the early 20th century presented a monumental challenge for both military and civilian physicians.

The Eloesser Flap surgical technique

Eloesser's approach to treating infected fluid around the lungs was groundbreaking. In 1935, he described a surgical technique that created a "window" in the chest wall to allow continuous open drainage of infected fluid—a low-cost alternative to expensive long-term hospitalization and isolation. The "Eloesser Flap" became a standard approach surgeons followed until effective antibiotics appeared in the 1940s. The technique embodied his lifelong philosophy: save lives through practical, low-cost interventions.

Treating gas wounds in World War I

This same philosophy had guided his earlier innovation during World War I. Having served on the front lines operating on wounded soldiers in Europe before the U.S. entry into the conflict, he recognized the urgent need for practical prosthetic design. When the U.S. Army later delayed establishing a prosthesis center for amputees, Eloesser commandeered Navy machinery at Mare Island and built an artificial limb factory, producing a low-cost, easy-to-attach device later called the "Letterman Leg" for the San Francisco military hospital where it was developed.


A simple easy to apply artificial leg

By the mid-1930s, Leo Eloesser was no longer an obscure surgeon with radical politics. He was an internationally recognized thoracic surgeon whose innovations had saved thousands of lives. His medical reputation was solid. But his heart remained elsewhere—in places where medicine met politics, where the stakes were survival itself, and where wealthy institutions could not insulate themselves from the world's violence.

Spain

In November 1937, the Spanish Civil War was in its second year. Franco's fascist insurgency, backed by Germany and Italy, was fighting the army of the democratically elected Republican government. The US, UK and France declared their neutrality, but then imposed an arms embargo which benefited Franco's side, since his forces had an ample flow of weapons from Germany and Italy.

While the embargo theoretically restricted weapons to both sides, Germany and Italy openly violated it, supplying Franco with aircraft, weapons, and military personnel. The Republicans, cut off by the embargo, had no effective way to rearm. Neutrality, in practice, meant fascism would prevail. Eloesser volunteered to serve as a surgeon for the Republican side.

The Spanish Civil War represented a sharp division not just in Spain and Europe, but also in America. Eloesser was one of over 2,800 Americans and 35,000 foreigners who volunteered for the Republican cause. At least 10,000 of the foreign volunteers and about 900 of the American volunteers died in the war.

While some commentators note that leftist and communist movements had grown strong after the years of the Depression, the depth of opposition to fascism ran far deeper and crossed ideological lines. George Orwell, no communist sympathizer, wrote his Homage to Catalonia after fighting in Spain—both as a socialist horrified by fascism and at the same time betrayed by communist manipulation. Ernest Hemingway's For Whom the Bell Tolls, published in 1940 after the Republican defeat: fascism was an immediate threat to civilization. Both works showed clearly that anti-fascism cut across ideology. One could oppose Hitler and Mussolini without being a communist, and many did.

Eloesser was fully committed to the Republican cause. Before leaving San Francisco, Eloesser raised fifty thousand dollars for an ambulance and surgical team, organized a programme to recruit other doctors, nurses and drivers. He was one of only twenty-one foreign physicians who would volunteer their expertise to the Spanish Republicans—a small, select international network of surgeons and doctors willing to cross political lines for principle.

Treating war wounds in Spain 1937

After reaching Spain he established a Mobile Surgical Hospital which worked along the frontlines of Teruel and the Ebro River—among the bloodiest battles of the war. He carried his viola with him.

The conditions were extreme. Coal and alcohol ran out, forcing Eloesser's team to sterilize surgical instruments on a kitchen stove fueled by scavenged wood. Air raids knocked out power lines; the surgical team operated by candle and pocket flashlights. To keep shock patients warm in freezing, bomb-damaged wards with shattered windows, staff laid mattresses directly on the floor around the kitchen stove.

Yet the team managed to run mobile field hospitals and establish a functional blood bank serving the wounded in some of the war's bloodiest battlefields. Despite everything—or perhaps because of everything—Eloesser learned a crucial lesson: effective medical care did not require expensive equipment or comfortable conditions. It required ingenuity, commitment, and will.

The Republican forces had largely collapsed by late summer 1938 and they formally surrendered to Franco in April 1939. In September 1939 Hitler's forces invaded Poland and WWII began. Much is made in popular history of Chamberlain's three "appeasement" meetings with Hitler in an attempt to stave off war. Little remembered is the arms embargo and supposed neutrality the US, UK and France declared when the war in Spain began with Nazi support in 1937.

Stranded in No Man's Land

By the time Eloesser and other American volunteers returned in the summer of 1938, they found that they had crossed a line. While many Americans celebrated their brave efforts to fight fascism, many political and business leaders did not. In fact, many in the establishment were openly sympathetic to Franco, Hitler, and Mussolini. Isolationists accused the returning Americans of disloyalty and having served a foreign dictator—Stalin—and helping fight for and fund "the other side".

When America entered World War II, Eloesser offered his extensive war surgery expertise to the United States Army. He was, after all, one of the finest thoracic surgeons in the country, with frontline experience from Spain.

The Army not only rejected him, they placed him on a blacklist. While he might have expected praise and welcome for working against fascism in a war against other fascist states, he found himself branded as "a premature anti-fascist." This was a euphemism of the time for individuals suspected of communist leanings. As Eloesser would later recall: "I was on the blacklist; 'Premature Anti-Fascist' it was called. I'd been in Spain. Anyone who had been in Spain was a Communist."

Of course there was another black mark on his record, the same one that had led to his rejection when he offered to help American forces when the US entered World War I—he had tended the wounded on the German side before the US entered the war. To the American military establishment, Eloesser's willingness to work across enemy lines in the name of healing made him suspect. He was deemed too radical, too sympathetic to causes that Washington viewed with hostility or indifference.

Barred from military service, he returned to his private surgical practice in San Francisco. It was respectable work, but it was not where his heart was. The world was at war. Fascism was advancing. He had proven himself on the battlefield, but now was confined to a consulting room in San Francisco.

In 1943, he left San Francisco to travel and lecture extensively through South America—Chile, Cuba, Argentina. He took up a position as an exchange professor of surgery in Buenos Aires. But he found himself at odds with what he saw there. Elite surgeons in air-conditioned operating rooms. Medicine as a privilege of the wealthy. Against this, his conviction deepened: "Health is the right of everyone, and not a privilege of a favored few. Health of the people can be achieved not by complicated and costly methods of surgical operations done in the ivory towers of electrically equipped and air-conditioned operating rooms, but by ordinary means within the grasp of every man; by killing flies and lice, by properly disposing sewage, by cleanliness and decent living."

Eloesser believed that millions of lives could be saved through basic hygiene, clean water, and simplified training for local health workers—not through expensive, highly technical Western hospital systems. Buenos Aires represented everything he had come to oppose: medicine as a commodity, healing as a service for the elite. It was not where the work that mattered most could happen.

The Trotsky Affair

Natalia, Frida, and Trotsky 1937

In 1937, Diego Rivera persuaded Mexican President Lázaro Cárdenas to grant political asylum to Leon Trotsky, Stalin's exiled rival. Trotsky and his wife Natalia Sedova came to live at Frida's home, the Casa Azul in Coyoacán. An affair briefly developed between Frida and Trotsky, but it faded, and Trotsky moved to a nearby house in Coyoacán.

On August 20, 1940, Trotsky was assassinated in his home by Ramón Mercader, a Soviet NKVD agent who had infiltrated Trotsky's circle. Mexican police launched a sweeping investigation, arresting anyone with ties to Trotsky—including Frida Kahlo and her sister Cristina. Frida was held and interrogated for two days. Though released without charges, the trauma, combined with the worsening agony in her spine and foot, pushed her to a physical and emotional breakdown.

Fearing further political harassment and needing urgent medical care, Frida fled to San Francisco in September 1940. She went straight to Leo Eloesser.

Eloesser admitted her to St. Luke's Hospital. He treated her kidney infection, managed her severe nerve pain, and put her on a strict regimen to regain her health. But he recognized that her physical suffering was deeply intertwined with her emotional distress over her divorce from Diego Rivera, which had been finalized in 1939.

Eloesser stepped in not just as a doctor, but as a mediator. He contacted Diego Rivera, who was also in San Francisco working on a mural for the Golden Gate International Exposition. Eloesser told Rivera plainly that Frida's health depended on their reconciliation, but laid down strict conditions for Rivera: he must support her financially so she could remain independent, and he must refrain from sexual relationships with other women.

Rivera agreed. On December 8, 1940—Diego's 54th birthday—Frida and Diego were remarried at San Francisco City Hall. Dr. Leo Eloesser was the official witness. It was Eloesser who had repaired the bond between Los Tres Amigos.

After UNICEF: Mexico and the Tacámbaro Project

Following his momentous five-year service with UNICEF in China—where he helped lay the foundation for community-based health care—Eloesser retired from international civil service in 1953. But he had no intention of retiring from medicine.

He settled permanently in Mexico, choosing the small town of Tacámbaro in the state of Michoacán. There, with his companion and later wife, Joyce Campbell, Eloesser established a rural health clinic and training project that brought to life the principles he had championed throughout his career.

In Tacámbaro, Eloesser focused on training indigenous women as traditional midwives and community health aides. Drawing directly on his experience in China, he authored a simple, illustrated manual for rural midwives titled Pregnancy, Childbirth, and the Newborn, published by the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO). The manual was translated into multiple indigenous languages and distributed throughout Latin America.

He refused to build an elaborate medical center. Instead, he worked out of a modest house, treating local campesinos for free, riding on horseback to mountain villages, and carrying his trusty viola to play music for the villagers in the evenings.

Dr. Leo Eloesser died in Tacámbaro on October 4, 1976, at the age of 95. He had lived an extraordinary life—as a pioneer of thoracic surgery, a battlefield surgeon in Spain, a savior and lifelong confidant to Frida Kahlo, and an architect of primary health care for the poor. The story of his China years—the Shijiazhuang strategy, the monastery training center, the barefoot doctors who would carry his vision forward—will be the subject of our next article.

Comments