Skip to main content

U.S.A.I.D. Cuts Killed People. That’s the Truth. From the NYT - shared by Kul Gautam

A fitting response to Trillionaire Elon Musk by Nick Kristof of the NY Times.

U.S.A.I.D. Cuts Killed People. That’s the Truth.

Musk insists that his demolition of humanitarian aid didn’t cost lives. So, I propose he take a trip with me.

From behind Twitter X's walls, the world's richest man scoffs at life-saving and empowering services that development aid offers to the world's poorest. But he refuses to listen to or debate those who hold contrary views grounded in lived experience and evidence.

Wish Musk would show a little bit of humility and empathy to balance his extraordinary wealth and hubris.

Comments

  1. Sudden aid cuts cost lives. Those wielding the axe cannot escape the moral consequences. However, we must be honest about why these cuts are fatal: decades of structural failure. By perpetuating a system of aid dependency, the development industry built a house of cards. For generations, international agencies and local governments chose the easy path of external funding instead of building resilient, self-sustaining local systems. The blame does not rest solely on the billionaires and politicians who cut the budgets. It belongs equally to the development architects who built systems so fragile that they collapse the moment foreign aid stops. If a life-saving system cannot survive without eternal external support, it is not sustainable. We should condemn the sudden demolition of humanitarian budgets, but we must also stop defending the dependency models that made millions so vulnerable in the first place.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Thomas. Parallel systems funded by external aid that bypass the accountability of host governments are ultimately unsustainable. They are also bound to create disruption once that external funding disappears.

    And lest anyone forget: those cutting aid are not just reckless figures like Trump or Musk. They also include elected officials in some of the world's most stable democracies, acting on the will of voters in the so called donor countries.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Please ensure you leave your name, bei either selecting your google account (if you have one), or selecting 'name' from the drop down menu. Enter your name there. If confused, leave your name in the text of your comment.